92 points - Wine Spectator December 2012
89 points - Gilbert & Gaillard April 2012
The strength of this golden-yellow wine is immediately pleasing to the nose while its complexity explodes on the palate. The initial notes of fruit are followed by more descreet aromas of brioche and vanilla when the wine is allowed to age in the bottle. Brut Carte Jaune offers a perfect balance of fineese and forcefulness.